Sorry to clog the forum with my elementary questions, but here goes another one. In Nutting exercise 51.
"When the wolf heard the dogs, he also crossed the stream".
A few lines later,
"When we saw the dead sailor in the woods, said Marcus, we ran to the farmhouse".
In the translation key, the cum clause in the first sentence is
Lupus, cum canes audivisset,
the second cum clause is
Nautam mortuum cum in silvis vidimus.
Why is the second cum clause in the perfect indicative and not in the
subjunctive pluperfect vidissemus as is the first cum clause? Both it seems are talking about actions which were prior to the action which comes afterward, which I thought calls for the subjunctive pluperfect. First Marcus saw the dead sailor, then he ran to the farmhouse.
question about the subjunctive
-
- Textkit Member
- Posts: 117
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2011 6:12 am
- bedwere
- Global Moderator
- Posts: 5101
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 10:23 pm
- Location: Didacopoli in California
- Contact:
Re: question about the subjunctive
cum + subjunctive has a semi-causal meaning. The wolf got the stimulus to cross the river from hearing the dogs.
cum + indicative is purely temporal. We happened to see a dead sailor and we ran to the farmhouse.
Sometimes the choice is nuanced and it depends on what feeling you wish to convey. You could have used the
cum + subjunctive in the second example.
cum + indicative is purely temporal. We happened to see a dead sailor and we ran to the farmhouse.
Sometimes the choice is nuanced and it depends on what feeling you wish to convey. You could have used the
cum + subjunctive in the second example.
Corrections are welcome (especially for projects).
Blogger Profile My library at the Internet Archive
Meae editiones librorum. Αἱ ἐμαὶ ἐκδόσεις βίβλων.
Blogger Profile My library at the Internet Archive
Meae editiones librorum. Αἱ ἐμαὶ ἐκδόσεις βίβλων.
-
- Textkit Member
- Posts: 117
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2011 6:12 am
Re: question about the subjunctive
Thanks Bedwere. Such subtle nuances are not mentioned in the textbooks that I know of. I still have trouble though hearing the word "when" (cum) at the start of a clause without hearing a causal ring (excluding poetry where everything goes).
-
- Textkit Member
- Posts: 117
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2011 6:12 am
Re: question about the subjunctive
Not true what I just wrote. "When" doesn't have to be causal and often isn't (When I went to the store, the sun came out),
but a sentence like "When we saw the dead sailor in the woods, we ran to the farmhouse" I can only hear as causal.
but a sentence like "When we saw the dead sailor in the woods, we ran to the farmhouse" I can only hear as causal.
-
- Textkit Fan
- Posts: 315
- Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2012 1:10 pm
Re: question about the subjunctive
I changed the key to the pluperfect subjunctive considering the information given in the textbook.
-
- Textkit Member
- Posts: 117
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2011 6:12 am
Re: question about the subjunctive
Would this be another such case? In Nutting exercise 52: "but when he heard the sea, he ran quickly to the boat...". The cum clause is translated as cum autem mare audiverat. Should this be audivisset?